Fingers Crossed.

Have you ever had one of those thoughts that seemed like a good idea at the time then suddenly you find yourself wrist-deep in cookie dough and the cat is trying to eat the styrofoam gravestones and somehow you spent a small fortune on things like faux cobwebs and glow-in-the-dark skeletons?

This weekend our house will be invaded by a handful of twelve year old girls hopped on on handfuls of sugar. Sugar that I will be providing in abundance. Sugar that I will be encouraging the consumption of. Sugar laid out in pretty packaging on pretty platters and in pretty bowls.

Let’s not forget this was all my idea. I claim full responsibility for any resulting cavities, scraped knees, overturned soda bottles, pumpkin carving injuries and popped eardrums.

I’m the sort of person that has the tendency to get a little carried away. Being creatively inclined I am all too familiar with the frustrating feeling that comes from imagination not matching up with reality. I have to remember I have a big imagination. This time I wanted to get it right. This time I wanted to throw an awesome party for Sable. This time I wanted her friends to talk about it for years to come.

So yeah, we pulled out all the stops. Fog machine, strobe light, spooky sounds CD, bubbling cauldron, dessert table, pumpkin carving, talking crows, ghost stories… The works!

And, of course, I couldn’t forget the classic Witch Finger Cookies. I’m sure you’ve seen them before. It’s nothing new, but I make them every year and I thought it was time to share them with you. Mine are a bit different. A little less blood and gore and more delicious almond flavour.

Just a little something to make the perfect Halloween party even better!

Almond Witch Finger Cookies

Makes about 2 dozen cookies.

Source: Adapted from my family recipe.

1 cup unsalted butter, room temperature
1 cup granulated sugar
1 egg
4 tbsp corn syrup
2 tsp almond extract
3 cup flour
1/4 tsp salt

Blanched almonds for garnish

Printer-Friendly Version

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees and position a rack in the center. Line your baking sheets with parchment paper then set them aside.

In a large bowl with an electric mixer cream together the butter and sugar until it’s light and fluffy. Add the egg, corn syrup and almond extract then beat it until it’s combined well.

In a medium bowl whisk together the flour and salt then add it to the butter mixture and mix it well.

Scoop a heaping tbsp of dough for each cookie and roll them into cylinders. Create knuckle shapes by rolling the cylinder lightly between two fingers then use a knife to make wrinkles on the knuckles. Taper one end slightly and lightly press an almond into it to form the fingernail.

Bake them for 10 minutes until the edges turn a light brown. Transfer them to a cooling rack and enjoy!

29 thoughts on “Fingers Crossed.

  1. Hester aka The Chef Doc

    What cool fingers, Lindsey! I’ve never made witch finger cookies before. I bet the almond tastes wonderful in these. Thanks so much for sharing your family recipe Have lots of fun!

  2. Katherine Martinelli

    I just love these!! A friend and I made them last year but they didn’t keep their shape quite as nicely as yours – these look perfect! And wonderful photographs Have fun this weekend!

    1. Lindsey

      Hi Katherine! The trick is not to add any leavening agents like baking soda or baking powder. A shortbread recipe would be perfect!

  3. Bimboca

    this are rwaly nice and i want to trie it, but your recipe is in cup, and i use gramm and i was searching bit it gives me so many diferentes values for 1 cup. Could you please give me de values por this recipe ins gramms? please? thank you

    1. Lindsey

      Hi there! I saw your comment on my facebook page and I answered your question there. I converted the recipe to grams for you. Have fun!

  4. Erin @ Dinners, Dishes and Desserts

    Your fingers are perfect! I have seen molds for these, that is about the only way mine would look half way decent. Sounds like a party your daughter will remember forever!

    1. Lindsey

      Thanks Erin! I’ve seen the molds too, but I never bothered with them. Forming them by hand is half the fun with me.

  5. Naomi

    Those fingers looks so delicious!

    I would like to making a batch of my own, but wondering could I use maple syrup instead of corn syrup?

    Or is there any substitution?


    1. Lindsey

      Hi Naomi. Maple syrup could work, but it’s possible it would make them spread out a bit more. I’ve used honey instead and it worked great!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *